Main Street Insurance Agency

At Main Street Insurance we like to make it easy to get an insurance quote and save people money but provide them with great services and coverage.

About Company

We are a full-service independent agency that has been serving Utah, Nevada, and 15 other states for 50 years and provides personal, commercial, life, and health insurance including Home, Auto, Business Insurance, Bonds, Workers Comp, Life, Health, and Medicare. Main Street Insurance has a staff of expert advisors in each insurance line to help individuals, families, self-employed, and small or large businesses with all their insurance needs.

Team Members

Brandon Johnson

Yesenia Arrey - Owner/Agent

Leslie Hofhein

Gene Arrey - Personal Agent

Sherri Talbot - Personal Agent

Hear From Our Customers

Main Street Insurance Agency
Based on 290 reviews
review us on
Very helpful, honest and quick responding with my multiple business ventures, my sometimes high demands and making sure I'm insured with the most appropriate and affordable insurance for all of my insurance needs. I've been with them for almost 10 years now. Can't go wrong with MSI!
Main Street Insurance is a great agency for all of my business insurance needs. My agent is patient, informative, and always finds the best companies to work with. I highly recommend them.
I got quick service and response from the agents I dealt with, and their pricing was better on the same products. I have been very happy with the help I've received from Main Street Insurance.
Aubree Klug is the best insurance agent ever! She is efficient, responsive, and provides the best coverage for reasonable premiums. I have recommended her to my neighbors who have changed companies to work with Aubree and have been very satisfied.
Kaleb is very helpful to get you what you need. He was also very informative, keeping you updated with progress and anvai options. I highly recommend Kaleb, and I will continue to use him.Thanks Kaleb for your help.
Kristen was great to work with and helped me save $100’s. After one of the competitors in town continuously raised my rates I started shopping around. Main Street was the best priced and Customer service is 10/10 Yes
Mainstreet helped quote me a few policies before we found the best fit for our auto policy. Yesi was great to work with and super responsive. She continues to answer any questions we have! 10.5/10!
Aubrey quoted/ wrote my policy. She was professional and knowledgeable. Got back with me on quote the same day. Aubrey took the time to explain the policy coverage. She wrote my policy with coverages and discounts that benefited me and tied in with my existing auto.
If you are looking for a great Insurance company for your Auto, Home, Umbrella or any other types of coverage, please do yourself a huge favor and at least get with Leslie Hofheins (or any of their excellent qualified representatives) who we were refered to because our insurance company who we were extremely loyal to for over 30 years was seriously gouging us. Leslie gave us quotes for apple to apple coverage and was able to save us a very significant amount of money. Main Street Insurance Agency has a 4.9/5 Star reviews with almost 300 Reviews and, to me, that speaks volumes of how they conduct their business. Their quotes are free and with absolutely no pressure sales or those extremely anoying phone calls. We feel the whole experience was A+ and simply couldn't give them a higher endorsement!
I HAD been a customer of a well-known insurance company for over 30 years, and I assumed they were taking care of me policy and premium wise. However, renewal after renewal the premiums increased outrageously without tickets or claims. A good friend of mine told me about Leslie Hofheins, an Agent at Main Street Insurance Agency, so I contacted her for quotes on my Home, Auto and Umbrella Policies with apples-to-apples coverage and within a few days, I received some excellent quotes saving me close to $1500 dollars/year! I'm not saying my other Insurance company was being dishonest and gouging me, but, Ok, yes, I am. If you are questioning the company that you do business with or if you are shopping around, stop and inquire here with Leslie. I'm beyond ecstatic with what she's done for me. Thank you, Lesile!
Main Street Insurance is extremely easy to work with and a Great Value compared to others. Our Agent is Aubree Klug, extremely friendly really listened to our needs as home owners. When you get to work with a Professional like Aubree things go much easier, my wife and I feel Aubree is above average in many respects and working with her was enjoyable plus we know that we will be taken care of if something arises with our home. Thanks Aubree! Matt & Brenda Vanartsdalen :)
Roxanne was incredibly helpful. She knows what she's doing, got me a rate I was happy with, and in a short amount of time. 10/10 would recommend!
Aubrey was very professional, efficient and explained the entire process of changing to a different insurance company in an easy to understand manner. Best of all, she saved us hundreds of dollars on our home and auto policies. I would highly recommend her to those looking for a policy change.
AMAZING!! I hesitated changing companies since I was to be "in Good Hands" with the company I had been with for 31 years. Not only did I receive a free quote but a comparison as well!! NO joke, we will be saving $300+ a month. WOW!! The agent Sherridan Talbot was very friendly, easy to work with, NOT pushy at all especially since I was wishy washy. I received emails promptly as I waited an extra 4 days to receive ANY information from my used to be insurance. Not only did I get an amazing rate, I will have more motorcycle, home & vehicle coverage!!
My husband and I were recommended by friends to contact Sherri Talbot for auto and home quote as our existing company made a huge increase at renewal . Sherri was super professional, very approachable and managed to get us a better deal . Highly recommend her !
Thank you Kaleb for your prompt and great service. I’ll be glad to recommend you to those looking for someone who can help them with their insurance needs.
Roxane and Kaleb DeMille were super great to work with and made the process super smooth for us. We appreciate all their work!
Been with Main Street Insurance for several years now and Aubree has always been incredibly helpful, dependable and knowledgeable. I’m incredibly satisfied with how organized and easy she has made the process for me. Thank you Aubree!
The Warner family has had a great experience with the team at Main Street Insurance. And highly recommend them to any one looking for an honest, friendly and accurate insurance plan for all of your insurance needs. Thank you Main Street Insurance for being so wonderful.
Brandon assisted us in determining if we should change our Part D prescription plan. We concluded that the plan we have was the best one for our prescription needs we currently have. He courteously spent time with us even though we did not purchase any insurance plan from him. It is nice to have an insurance agent who is local to work with instead of over the phone in a different state.