Keystone Insurance Services

Serving all of Utah for the best Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Landlord Insurance, and Umbrella Insurance.

About Company

“Keystone Insurance Services has been proudly representing Bear River Mutual Insurance since 2003. The relationship with our clients (and their rave reviews) keep us excited to continue helping the communities throughout Utah obtain coverage and stay protected with auto insurance, home insurance, landlord insurance, and umbrella insurance. We’re a family owned three-generation insurance agency who’s committed to the unique values found right here in Utah. We hope that that legacy continues to grow for generations to come.

Understanding the intricate details of insurance coverage is essential in advising the correct policy and endorsements for each particular customer, and that’s where we shine. Whether you’re looking for auto insurance, or any other coverage for your family, we hope that you trust us to offer you the best rates with Bear River Mutual no matter where you’re located in the great state of Utah”

Our Locations

Team Members

Keystone Insurance team

Keystone team

Hear From Our Customers

Crystal M. B.
8 months ago
I have really enjoyed working with this company. They always work to find me better deals on my car insurance and are great to send me reminders when my policy needs to be reviewed. Highly recommend!
Kynsie Sessions
8 months ago
Ashlee Baires
8 months ago
Eli was a wonderful help when we had a last minute requirement for our home refinance, and without even asking she requoted us with different carriers and was able to get us two different policies that met the requirements and also saved us $300 a year! All in one afternoon too! I’d definitely recommend her!
Jamie Christiansen
8 months ago
Thanks!
Larry Entze
8 months ago
Daniela Romero Of Keystone Insurance services is a very wonderful representative She is very quick knowing answers and took the time to help me understand I would highly recommend her Sincerely Larry Entze
Ashley Gil
8 months ago
Daniela was great in helping me and my family find cheaper coverage on our car insurance. I am very happy with the customer service I received from her. This is a huge relief budget-wise to have found the same coverage but cheaper. Thank you!
Betty Garcia
8 months ago
Isaac Sainteran
8 months ago
Shealee Heise helped me find the best rate possible for my home loan. I am very grateful for that
Peg Baack
9 months ago
I was helping my grandson who is a student at UVU find an affordable insurance policy quickly. I wanted to find him an agent in the town where he currently lives. After looking for car insurance agencies with good ratings in Orem, I found Keystone Insurance agency. I gave them a call and was very lucky to be transferred to Celia. Celia understood what we were looking for and within a very short time, helped my grandson and I find an affordable policy with a reputable Insurance company. She was very friendly and patient & knew immediately what we were looking for. I recommend Celia and Keystone very highly.
Ken Kondo
9 months ago
Very cost efficient, simple, and thorough with replacing my existing contract. I appreciate the timely following up to insure my family home.
Kenna Wahlquist
11 months ago
Nathan, I wanted to thank you for going the extra mile today to get me into a great policy. I appreciate how quick and thorough the experience was. It’s always great to talk to someone that cares. I will surely be in touch for any other insurance needs thanks again.
Daniel Dunnigan
12 months ago
Traci Diamond was professional, helpful, friendly, and competent. She was very responsive. She quickly found us a policy that fits our needs. The price is better than we expected for what we needed. She did what she said she would do and maintained open communications.
River gatten
1 year ago
Traci was awesome! Great working with her, she worked around my schedule and got me a great deal super fast! Would get my auto insurance with her again and again.
Heidi Schiers
1 year ago
Sheree was amazing! Very quick to respond to my text. I needed to transfer coverage to a new insurance and I had answers and was good to go within a short period of time. Thank you for all of your help!
Jarod Santiago
1 year ago
They got in contact with me very quickly. And upon walking in not only were they friendly but Celia helped me and my wife with our car insurance and finding the right plan for us. From when I first got in contact with her and to when we signed was just perfect. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience.
Sadie Young
1 year ago
Traci with Keystone was able to get me a better deal with three vehicles than I was paying for two at my previous insurance company. I was so relieved. She was so kind and personable and knowledgeable. I would recommend her to anyone.
Jean Irwin
1 year ago
After filling out an online request for comparative insurance prices, I was deluged with phone calls and texts. I called a company my kids recommended and asked to speak to a human. The human turned out to be Traci Diamond who was kind, non-patronizing, answered endless questions, and didn't slip into ageism. She quickly helped me find insurance for my car at a much lower rate from what had been deducted from my state payroll for 34 years. Not only was she efficient, her immediate help and follow-through was amazing during a difficult time for my family, even answering questions while I was at the airport. She walked me through everything including helping me cancel my previous auto policy. She helped me resolve that which had caused this new retiree much stress. AND, she wasn't the proverbial pushy insurance salesperson. I remain intrigued and grateful, beyond measure. When I described my experience to my family and some friends, they were equally amazed. This company should treasure Traci Diamond. I certainly do.
Celia Rodriguez was quick and to the point. She didn't try to upsell anything and listened to what type of coverage we needed. The process with Keystone Insurance has by far been the quickest and friendliest service we received. I highly recommend them if you're looking for GREAT service at an affordable price!
I loved working with Traci! She was super helpful and responsive to all of my questions throughout the whole process. I ended up saving $70 / month on my auto policy with essentially the same coverage. I look forward to utilizing her expertise with any future insurance needs.
Lexi Kellogg
2 years ago
Collette was above and beyond expectations! She made getting a commercial auto and business policy seamless at incredible rates…Not to mention at 7pm ON A FRIDAY.
Mark Palsson
2 years ago
As an HOA treasurer, we have used Keystone insurance since the beginning twenty one years ago. They are always responsive and have helped to keep our premiums low. I’ve also changed our personal policy over to them. Their personalized service is hard to beat.
h tigerlily
2 years ago
Jason was wonderful. Fast and responsive to our questions and concerns. He made sure we had a quote before he left on Friday and then followed up with us repeatedly during the process. By Tuesday we had our auto insurance and home insurance moved. The prior company had planned to charge us 5000 more for our renewal. He even beat our current rate. Couldn't ask for better!
Kurt Romney
2 years ago
I had the privilege of working with Traci Diamond to find better auto and homeowner's insurance. She was very responsive and delivered excellent service and results.
Linda Sandaklie
2 years ago
Wonderful job from the agent of the insurance company, Sheree Russell! Fast reply and ability to provide the information about the home insurance! Very helpful! Thank you so much for your amazing job! Highly recommend the insurance company!
Raymond Byrnes
2 years ago
Highly recommend. I had a policy that was about to expire and was surprised to hear from them first to let me know what my options were. Quick resolution and great communication. Thank you