Deductibles are increasing on auto and home policies beginning April 15, 2024. Please carefully review your renewal policy and reach out to your agent with any questions.

Insuring Each Other for Less

We live and work in Utah. It makes sense that we want
to insure our neighbors at the best price.

Unbiased Options

We work exclusively with independent agents so you
can be assured the best options will be presented even
if it’s another insurance company!

Financial Protection

Accidents, theft, and storms are just some of the things
that can come with a heavy financial consequence.
Find out how we can help.

We Don’t Insure Everyone

We insure the Best Drivers and Most Responsible Homeowners.
Saying no to some keeps rates lower for others.

Local people solve local problems

Not only will we pronounce your city correctly, chances
are we know the best people in your area when help
is needed.

1. Priced Right for Utah

2. Independent Agents

3. Coverage that Matters

4. Responsibility

5. Doing What Others Can’t

We Know Utah

We are one of the largest personal lines carriers in Utah for a reason. As a Utah only company, our local employees, network of independent agents, and preferred contractors and repair facilities understand what makes Utah, Utah!

Set for Life

Trusted by Generations

We have been providing financial backing to Utah residents since 1909. You can say we are a family tradition.

Trusted by Thousands

Local, Mutual Insurance

We serve members, not stockholders. You can rest easy knowing events in other parts of the country won’t impact your rates.

Total Payment Transparency

The Right Options

Whether it be lifestyle discounts or special coverages, our network of independent agents are positioned to serve your needs and interests.

Protecting what is important to you

You worked hard for what you have. Bear River Mutual knows how to protect it. All of our policies come with the financial backing and service of company that understands why insurance matters.

Auto Insurance

Our Auto Policy rewards your impeccable driving habits with premium protection, embodying our vision to insure the best drivers.

Home Insurance

In line with our mission of ‘Mutually insuring each other for less’, our Home Policy offers comprehensive coverage for the most responsible homeowners. Secure your sanctuary with us, and become a part of our vision to protect the safest homes.

Condo Insurance

Navigating through condominium insurance can be tricky. That’s why our Condominium Policy offers comprehensive coverage that aligns perfectly with condo living, providing protection for your unit and personal possessions.

Renters Insurance

Just because you don’t own it, doesn’t mean you don’t protect it. Our Renters Policy is designed to shield your personal belongings and provide liability coverage in a rental property, ensuring you feel right at home.

Dwelling Insurance

Our Dwelling Policy provides specialized coverage that protects the structure of your rental property, securing your investment from unforeseen incidents.

Umbrella Insurance

In a world filled with uncertainties, our Umbrella Policy provides that extra layer of liability protection beyond your other policies, keeping you and your assets well-covered in all circumstances.

Bear River Mutual in Numbers

Years in Utah
+
Agency Offices
+
Repair Centers
Preferred Contractors

Hear From Our Customers

Bear River Mutual Insurance CompanyExcellentBear River Mutual Insurance Company4.5 Based on 1819 reviews fromSee all reviews review us on ★★★★★ When a kid drove into the back of my brand new custom-ordered Kia EV6 while I was stopped on the freeway with all 6 lanes of traffic, his insurance company was a royal pain to work with, even though I was parked almost next to the UHP officers working on the first accident when the kid hit me, and it was CLEARLY the kid's fault. It took them over 3 months to decide my car was totaled, and they offered me 2/3 of what I had paid for it a month before the accident. So, on the advice of my Bear River agent, I called Bear River Claims. They paid me almost what I paid for the car, and went after the kid's insurance and the kid to get the rest - and I didn't have to lift a finger. The agent and the adjuster were so good to work with - it only took them a week to see the car was totaled and another week to get me my check so I could replace my car.Dave McNeill ★★★★★ I’ve been a customer with Bear River for 20+ years. Recently had a wind damage to my roof. I had a claim and they responded fast and paid for my roof to get replaced. Tracy was great to work with.Edin Odobasic ★★★★★ Do you want to be unfazed by insurance commercials? Do you want responsive agents, expert advice at your fingertips, and an insurance company who is truly in your corner? Look no further. These are your people.My mother has been with them since I can remember, and I've been involved with one policy or another since I was 16. My agent, James Pratt, has been with me, literally, through growing up---managing insurance policies for new cars, (the resulting tickets of those new cars, which was much cheaper than I'd feared) purchasing renter's insurances, and has always ensured the day-to-day functions are completely taken care of. He is so friendly, professional, and knows exactly what he is doing. I am confident that I am both getting the best rates, because he truly cares about his clients, and also the best service.This company feels small in a sense that is comforting in a world in which seems to be getting bigger and faster every second, and they have consistently stayed that way. They are gem hidden in plain sight.Leon Ross ★★★★★ I had an amazing experience with my most recent claim I had with Bear River (I know, insurance company and I said "amazing experience"). I recently totaled my vehicle (sad day) and Bear River quickly processed my claim and reached a fair settlement with me. The only complaint that I have is that you have to work with multiple adjusters for the same claim. For example, I had one adjuster that took care of the actual claim and then another to work with me on medical issues. I think that they should just have one adjuster work on the same claim. I believe it would make the process smother, less complicated and less confusing. But my overall experience was definitely five stars and I would recommend them to my family and friends.Scott Buckley ★★★★☆ Love them, the rate is going on over the years and I have had no problems when I have the other insurance companies that will increase my insurance without even telling me Steven when I had no accident. Bear River mutual insurance doesn't do thatJacqui Beckford (Jacqui's Creative Designs) ★★★★★ We switched to Bear River Mutual about 2 years ago. We recently purchased a new car and in the first we were in a wreck. It was really a horrible situation. The team at Bear River were truly amazing helping us through the process and we think they were generous in providing a settlement. The best insurance company we have worked with in the past 40 years.Mark Widmer ★★★★★ They are the best insurance company. I love that they are local, and I truly consider Andy a friend. He always answers his phone and responds quickly. He looks our for me and my family. We have been with this company for years.Marisa Wilson ★★★★★ My wife and I have been with Bear River for around 30 years without a single claim (other than windshield chip repairs). We then suffered wind damage with unusually strong wind storms (2) and I shyly submitted a claim. Bear River came through and took great care of us. I would highly recommend them to everyone.Mark Dayley ★★★★★ Quick service and very trustworthy... I am very happy with bear river mutual in resolving my claim. I highly recommend them . This is the first time I had to put a claim in using this insurance. They were very easy to work with and explained everything so I could understand.Fran Henriquez ★★★★★ I've loved being a customer of Bear River for home insurance for over 10 years. However, after a single bad year of us having a number of claims for some plumbing, mold and other issues, Bear River opted to not renew our policy for 2024. I understand the calculation for underwriting policies that a smaller company like Bear River has to make, but we were disappointed that Bear River chose to part ways with us after covering our issues this last year.Charles Beckmann ★★★★★ Bear River's service was quick and professional. They took care of communications with the garage and the rental company. Their service totally exceeded my expectations. Thank you!Pascal Langevin ★★★★★ When our home flooded, we were devastated. Our claims specialist was sympathetic, helpful, and very responsive throughout the entire process. She made things so much easier and helped get our home put back together in a timely manner. We are so grateful for Bear River Mutual and their employees.Richardson Team ★★★★★ Bear River and our rep, Jayden at Bear River is amazing. He is always there for us. He always picks up the phone. He has saved us over $1000 a month with his comments on how we can save. We converted our home owners insurance with him because him and Bear River does such a great job. The coverage is amazing. They never cut corners and the end products always are 5 star. Thx for all your help Jayden.Nikkie Stone ★★★★★ I have had a great experiences working with Bear River Insurance on a few claims over the last 10years. They have been professional, informative and helped me through a difficult situation with getting the our cars taken care of. I would highly recommend Bear River. We have been with Bear River for 15+ years and have all of our vehicles that they cover (they don't cover UTV's or Boats) with them including our home owners insurance. thanks for the great service and prices.Brian Stanley ★★★★★ Unfortunately, I had a claim on my car insurance; however, Bear River made the process quick and easy. I had a person I could call about the claim anytime and when I called them, I was able to get meaningful answers. The insurance claim payment was very fair and we were able to complete the entire claim process in less than 3 weeks. This included estimates on the damage, decisions by the claim adjuster and receiving the check. I never heard from the other parties in the claim, so I would assume their claims were also satisfied.Glenn Fassmann ★★★★★ I had left a bad review to begin with but my mind and heart has changed. I was able to get in contact with Brandon, Nathan’s supervisor and we settled things for the better. I appreciate Bear River for calling me back about my review and making sure the problem gets resolved. I appreciate their help and making sure that as a claimant I get what I deserve. I wish them nothing but success in the future!🤙🏾Maa Notoa ★★★★★ What can I say other than YOU'RE ALL AMAZING!!! I've only been with you since I was 16! Best prices, best agents, best customer service, THE ABSOLUTE BEST at insurance! After my car was totalled (not my fault!), I called in to file my claim. The process was so easy and hassle free! The team I worked with took care of everything, and I was in another vehicle of my own 8 days later! That's incredible! It's been that way for every claim I've ever had! Thank you for being the BEST with the GREATEST PEOPLE!!!Heather Hodges ★★★★★ Working with my claims adjuster at Bear River has been a great experience. She has been professional and so helpful, as well as showing true care and concern for what we are going through. I would recommend Bear River to everyone!Walter Hammond ★★★★★ I have used Bear River for many years. The rates are good and when I had a claim, It was taken care of quickly and painlessly. I call my agent Josh every year to make sure I am getting the best rates. Most of the times he is able to do so but he also is understanding when I have to use another carrier.Walter G ★★★★★ I have been with Bear River Mutual for many years. My experience has been very good. I have compared their rates with other companies, and find they have the best rates available. I have experienced serval accidents during my time with Bear River Mutual. Their response has always been timely and helpful. I recently had such an experience with my pickup truck. Once again, I was reminded why I stay with Bear River. Their friendly and timely service to me was greatly appreciated. I was provided with a rental car while my repair was completed and my truck is once again good as new. Thanks Bear River.Joseph Harmanjs_loader
Bear River Mutual agent

Interested in becoming a Bear River Mutual agent?

Let us know a little bit about yourself!